Peter Sciacca

It didn't take long for Peter to turn it up a notch and start to ask him about the things he likes to do sexually. The decoy expressed frustration about not being able to come out in his conservative neighborhood, fearing physical assault. Peter replied to this by asking if he wants a secret lover. They also spoke over the phone where they talked about getting away from Georgia together. As the decoy expresses boredom in the conversation and tried to get off the phone, Sciacca tried coaxing the decoy to remain on the phone to no avail.

Peter would drive two hours in his Hummer H3 SUV from the Atlanta suburb of Norcross to the sting house. It is drizzling outside when he pulls up. He automatically figures out something is wrong when Del Harvey , as the decoy, comes out with her face covered up trying to wave him in. Her voice is several octaves lower than the decoy Peter spoke with on the phone, who sounded like he was still growing into his voice. She also put a southern twang into her voice, which the phone decoy did not have. Suspicious, Peter asks Del to take her hat off to get a better look and heads back to his car when she refuses. He is quickly arrested by officers from the Harris County Sheriff's Office, never getting a chance to be confronted by Chris Hansen . As he was being carted away, the Dateline camera crew zoomed in on his face, to which Peter politely asked for them to get the camera out of his face.

Chris Hansen mispronounces Peter's last name as "See-kah" in his post-production voiceover. ”Don Cheech” is also the name of a restaurant in Staten Island New York.