Glenn D. Mitchell

He lived in Carmel, Indiana. Glenn was first caught by Perverted Justice in 2003. Glenn would get in touch with a contributor whenever they set up a decoy in the Mid-West Region. He had a toll-free number that underage boys could use to contact him for free.

Police raided Glenn's Indiana apartment after his arrest. They found child pornography and seized three laptops that contained videos and phone numbers that linked him to Darke County, Ohio. Glenn initially resisted being sent to Ohio through extradition, but Darke County eventually managed to do so. He was charged with felony Attempted Unlawful Sexual Contact with a Minor. He was found guilty of the charge and sentenced to ninety-two days in jail and three years of probation. Glenn was labeled a child sexual predator by Judge Jonathan Hein of the Darke County Common Pleas Court. Glenn must register with the sheriff's office in his county of residence every ninety days for the remainder of his life. Later, he moved from Illinois to Darke County, Ohio, where he is recognized as a Child Victim Predator.

Joey found a number associated with Mitchell and called it. Mitchell texted Joey , pretending to be Kevin Westerbeck . He tried to call him back several times, but in an attempt not to scare Mitchell off, he stuck to texting and pretended he was looking for Mitchell's roommate, Joe, who is also a registered sex offender. According to a police report, Mitchell and Joe had been involved in two separate police calls over nasty arguments, one of which was due to Mitchell being concerned Joe wasn't wearing enough warm clothing in the winter. When Joey and Mitchell spoke on the phone, Mitchell remained nervous about who he was talking to, claiming that he hadn't seen Joe in over a year.

When Chris Hansen contacted Mitchell for his podcast, Mitchell answered the phone despite having been asleep. Not initially recognizing Hansen's name or voice, Hansen told Mitchell why he was calling and who he was, and after some hesitation, Mitchell claimed that he was retired and successful. While acknowledging his crimes, he expressed no interest in speaking to Hansen about his conviction or charges before telling him to find someone else to talk to and hanging up. According to public records, Hansen ran a background check and discovered Mitchell is not known to have reoffended since 2006.