Case index

To Catch a Predator · Flagler Beach investigation

David Wagner

David John Wagner received a five-year prison sentence in the Flagler Beach sting case. That term ran concurrently with a separate seven-year sentence from Duval County.

Photo: To Catch a Predator Wiki

Outcome
Sentenced
Evidence
Attributed reporting
Jurisdiction
Flagler Beach, Florida
Encounter
Not established
Decoy posed as
Girl4
Case number
0601146

Personal details

Born
December 6, 1982
Marital status
Single
Height
6′02″
Weight
188 lb.
Hair
Bald
Eyes
Brown

Charges & sentence

0601146

  1. Attempted lewd or lascivious battery

    Guilty plea

    Convicted51

  2. Internet solicitation of a minor for sexual conduct

    Guilty plea

    Convicted51

  3. Transmission of harmful material to a minor

    Guilty plea

    Convicted51

Sentence

Five years in prison for the Flagler Beach case, concurrent with a separate seven-year Duval County term; later lifetime probation and registration are also described.

Attributed to the sources below. Consult the original record for full terms.

Case records

0601146Hansen investigation · 2009 · Sentenced
Case number
0601146

0601146

  1. Attempted lewd or lascivious battery

    Guilty plea

    Convicted51

  2. Internet solicitation of a minor for sexual conduct

    Guilty plea

    Convicted51

  3. Transmission of harmful material to a minor

    Guilty plea

    Convicted51

Sentence · Aug 11, 2009

Five years in prison for the Flagler Beach case, concurrent with a separate seven-year Duval County term; later lifetime probation and registration are also described.51

  • Prison: 5 years · concurrent51

Reviewed sting-related legal outcome. Do not add the separate seven-year Duval sentence or its three-year probation to the sting case. Lifetime probation timing and case ownership remain insufficiently clear for numeric structured promotion. Distinct from David Michael Wagner in Michigan. Saved affidavit is an arrest document, not sentencing proof.

Sources 51

0711851Separate criminal matter · 2009 · Sentenced
Case number
0711851

0711851

  1. Lewd or lascivious battery involving a minor

    Guilty plea

    Convicted4

  2. Tampering with or intimidating a witness

    Guilty plea

    Convicted4

  3. Contributing to the delinquency of a minor

    Dismissed4

Sentence · Mar 31, 2009

Reported seven-year Duval prison term followed by three-year probation; Flagler term was later ordered concurrent. Agency lists battery terms of seven years and witness intimidation of five years.41

  • Prison: 7 years · concurrent41
  • Probation: 3 years4

Distinct offenses involving an actual minor after sting arrest, not another sting. Two agency battery rows have distinct offense dates but are not converted to two legal counts without judgment. Final lifetime supervision statement is not safely assigned to a specific later order. Registry status and historical release do not establish current custody.

Sources 41

Case narrative

Sting

It took David about an hour to drive to the sting house in Flagler Beach. After making small talk with the decoy, Chris Hansen came out and questions him. When David inquired about an open house, Chris responded hilariously that it was another kind of open house. David claimed he merely wanted to "meet a friend" when he came over to the house. When he tried to leave, Chris stopped him and told him to sit down again. David complied and answered more questions. David then maintained that he left his car lights on. David is halted by Chris, who revealed that he was aware of David's desire to drive the girl in his car. David promised to return and dashed out of the house. Before he could escape, he was arrested by police.

Since David chose his right to remain silent before even being taken into the interrogation room, no police interview is available unlike all the other predators caught in this sting.

Aftermath

He was arrested again in May of 2007 in Duval County for sex offenses against the real child. For the case involving the real child, David pleaded guilty to charges of lewd or lascivious battery, and tampering with a witness, victim, or informant. A charge of contributing to the delinquency of a minor was dropped. He was sentenced in March 2009 to seven years in prison, followed by three years of probation. In August 2009, David was then found guilty in the Flagler Beach case. He pleaded guilty to child exploitation, transmission of harmful material to a minor, and attempted lewd, lascivious battery sex with a victim 12-15 years old. He was sentenced to five years in prison to be served concurrently with the Duval sentence. After his release from prison, David was designated a sexual predator in Florida and received lifetime probation and lifetime sex offender registration. He later moved out of Florida to Tucson, Arizona. Shockingly, despite actually having sex with a minor, David was classed as a Tier I sex offender and did not have to have his registry details public in Arizona, as only Tier II and Tier III offenders have to have their information public.

Community-written, from the To Catch a Predator Wiki. Not independently verified, and it does not establish charges or court outcomes.

David Wagner, To Catch a Predator Wiki contributors; see revision and history links. · CC-BY-SA

Media

Sources

  1. 1David John Wagner historical prison sentencesPublic agency · Florida Department of Corrections · Checked Oct 23, 2026J38893 lists Duval0711851 sentenced March31,2009: two battery rows of seven years and a witness-intimidation row of five years. Flagler0601146 was sentenced August11,2009: attempted battery, internet offense and harmful-information rows of five years. Repeated rows are not automatically count quantities or aggregate terms.
  2. 297: David Wagner on MegaphoneOriginal publisher · Megaphone · Published Nov 28, 2022 · Checked Oct 23, 2026Public episode metadata matches the publisher RSS recording by title, release date and exact enclosure identifier. Reviewed publisher title/description names this profile as the subject of the recording.
  3. 397: David Wagner on SpotifyOriginal publisher · Spotify · Published Nov 28, 2022 · Checked Oct 23, 2026Public episode metadata matches the publisher RSS recording by title, release date and exact enclosure identifier. Reviewed publisher title/description names this profile as the subject of the recording.
  4. 4David Wagner (community wiki)Community wiki · unverified · To Catch a Predator Wiki contributors · Updated Aug 12, 2026 · Checked Oct 23, 2026Attributed community article. Revision date describes the article update, not a court or sting event. Full infobox, narrative sections, references and assets are retained in the private archive.

An on-camera appearance does not establish guilt. Charges, court outcomes, and reported information are kept distinct. Research standards

Record updated Oct 23, 2026 · Version 5 · Suggest a correction